Proclear® toric and Biofinity® toric are two of the most popular toric contact lenses on the market today. They share many similarities, so determining which brand is best for you may be difficult. But don’t fret — Lens.com is here to help. In this guide, we’ll compare Proclear toric and Biofinity toric and discuss their features, including their wearing and replacement schedules, price, and more. After reading this guide and consulting with your eye care professional (ECP), you’ll be better equipped to decide which of these two toric contacts is right for you.
|Brand||Proclear toric||Biofinity toric|
|Wearing schedule||Daily wear or up to 7 days of extended wear||Daily wear or up to 7 days of extended wear|
|Replacement schedule||Monthly replacement||Monthly replacement|
|Material||Lotrafilcon B (67% polymer)||Comfilcon A (52% polymer)|
|Vision problems corrected||– Nearsightedness
|Special features||– HydraGlyde Moisture Matrix
– SmartShield Technology
– Visibility tint
– Wetting agent
|– Aquaform Technology
– Aberration Neutralizing System
– Visibility tint
|Lenses per box||6 lenses per box (6-month supply)||6 lenses per box (6-month supply)|
What are toric contact lenses?
Toric contact lenses correct astigmatism — a common and generally treatable imperfection in the eye’s curvature that causes blurred near and distance vision. In a person with astigmatism, either the cornea or the lens is curved so that the eye’s refraction differs between the vertical and horizontal planes. This causes blurred vision. In some cases, vertical lines will also appear to tilt. The unique shape of toric contacts allows them to focus light using different refractive (focusing) powers between the vertical and horizontal planes. The same effect cannot be achieved with standard contacts, which have a spherical shape.
Fit and stability are incredibly crucial for toric contacts. Toric contacts have a middle axis, much like the Earth’s equator. The contacts need to stay put along that axis so that the wearer’s line of vision remains clear. If the contacts don’t fit perfectly or if they keep rotating on the eye, the wearer will experience blurred vision.
Proclear toric and Biofinity toric in Detail
Proclear toric and Biofinity toric are designed to correct astigmatism. Both contact lenses are made by CooperVision, one of the world’s leading manufacturers of soft contacts.
Wearing and Replacement Schedules Proclear toric and Biofinity toric are monthly disposable contacts, meaning they can be worn for up to 30 days before being thrown away. However, only Biofinity toric contacts are FDA-approved for up to seven days of extended wear, making them a better option than Proclear toric for people with unpredictable schedules, such as busy professionals, military personnel, and emergency workers.
Fit and Stability As toric contacts, both Proclear toric and Biofinity toric do a great job staying put on the eye. But they don’t work the same way. Proclear toric contacts are specially designed to provide on-eye stability, while Biofinity toric use unique Optimized Toric Lens Geometry to ensure a stable fit and minimal lens movement, even if you blink or move your eyes quickly.
Comfort Both Proclear toric and Biofinity toric also deliver superior comfort, but how they go about that is very different. Proclear toric contacts use exclusive PC Technology, which attracts water to the lenses to help them remain fresh and comfortable all day long. The Proclear lens material also helps prevent eye irritation by resisting deposit buildup.
Meanwhile, Biofinity toric contacts use Aquaform Technology, which locks in water to ensure all-day comfort. Biofinity toric contacts also have smooth, rounded edges. These edges enhance comfort by minimizing interaction between the contact lens and the eyelid.
Material Proclear toric and Biofinity toric also differ in terms of lens material. Proclear toric contacts are made of hydrogel, while Biofinity toric contacts are silicone hydrogel.
Hydrogel is a water-infused polymer that has high biocompatibility with the human eye. This means our bodies do not produce a negative immunological response when exposed to hydrogel. Hydrogel can also hold large amounts of water, which is why hydrogel contacts aren’t likely to dry out throughout the day. Silicone hydrogel, on the other hand, is a polymer that contains both hydrogel and silicone — a gel-like polymer with a high degree of flexibility. Like hydrogel, silicone hydrogel also contains water. However, it allows much more oxygen to pass through to the eye than hydrogel. This is why silicone hydrogel contacts are suitable for overnight or extended wear.
The only downside of silicone hydrogel contacts is their tendency to collect deposits. Silicone hydrogel contacts are also not an option for people who are allergic or sensitive to silicone.
Price Proclear toric contacts typically retail for $50 to $95 per box of six lenses, with each box lasting six months. If you wear Proclear toric contacts regularly, expect an annual lens cost of $200 to $380. On Lens.com, these contacts start as low as $43.29 per box of six lenses after rebates.
Meanwhile, Biofinity toric contacts typically retail for $40 to $75 per box of six lenses, with each box lasting six months. If you wear Biofinity toric contacts regularly, expect an annual lens cost of $160 to $300. On Lens.com, these contacts can cost as low as $17.99 per box of six lenses after rebates.
Note that these prices are accurate as of 05/16/22 but are subject to change without notice.
Conclusion: which toric contact lens is for you?
Fit and stability are the two most important factors to consider when choosing toric contacts. Both Proclear toric and Biofinity toric excel in these areas, so you may want to consider how they differ.
For instance, Proclear toric contacts are intended for daily wear only, while Biofinity toric contacts are FDA-approved for up to seven days of continuous wear. Are you okay with removing your contacts every night before you sleep? Do you like the idea of inserting your contacts one morning and then forgetting about them for the next few days? Your answer to these questions and recommendations from your ECP, will determine the best contact lens wearing schedule for you.
If comfort is a top priority for you, consider the lens material and any special features to improve comfort. Hydrogel contacts, like Proclear toric, stay moist longer than silicone hydrogel contacts, like Biofinity toric. However, you can’t wear them to bed, and they may become less comfortable after many hours of wear. Biofinity toric contacts are exceptionally breathable, but they may be less comfortable on sensitive eyes. Since they’re prone to deposit buildup, they also require regular cleaning. Plus, they’re not suitable for people who are allergic or sensitive to silicone.
This information is intended as a resource, not medical advice. Be sure to consult with your ECP to determine your specific needs.